Abstract
Refuse deposited by members of the Theosophical Institute in San Diego, California, ca. 1900–1920 provides a basis for defining patterns that reflect the idiosyncratic lifeways of the people who lived there. Comparisons with assemblages from urban and rural sites of the same period allow isolation of the areas of divergence. The Theosophical Society assemblage has low proportions of consumer items and bottled products along with lower values for ceramic tableware price scaling. Dietary differences were noted, as well, and the refuse has a large number of homeopathic medicine vials, reflecting specialized health practices. The patterns noted indicate less than full participation in the consumer society of the time and deviations in diet and healing practices from those of the mainstream society, and may have served as boundary markers, reinforcing the sense of group membership and cohesiveness.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Aryan Theosophical Press 1922 Katherine Tingley’s Raja-Yoga System of Education: Its Aims and Achievements. The Aryan Theosophical Press, Point Loma, CA.
Atherton, May Davidson 1982 Oral interview with Sylvia Arden, 11 September. Transcript on file, San Diego County Historical Society Research Archives, San Diego, CA.
Benté, Vance G. 1975 Trash Pits, Privies, and Promises. In 3,500 Years on One City Block, Roberta S. Greenwood, editor, pp. 209–294. Report to Redevelopment Agency, San Buenaventura, CA, from Greenwood and Associates, Pacific Palisades, CA.
Benté, Vance G. 1976 Well, a Borrow Pit, and Six Privies. In The Changing Faces of Main Street, Roberta S. Greenwood, editor, pp. 299–350. Report to Redevelopment Agency, San Buenaventura, CA, from Greenwood and Associates, Pacific Palisades, CA.
Blanford, John 1987 Overseas Chinese Ethnicity and Euroamerican Glass Bottles at the Wong Ho Leun Site. In Wong Ho Leun: An American Chinatown, Vol. 2, Clark W. Brott, ed., 189–232. Great Basin Foundation, San Diego, CA.
Brock, James 1985 Excavations in Early Santa Ana: The OCTD Terminal Site [CA-ORA-103H]. Report to Orange County Transit District, Garden Grove, CA, from ECOS Management Criteria, Cypress, CA.
Brownlee, W. Elliott 1979 Household Values, Women’s Work, and Economic Growth, 1800–1930. The Journal of Economic History 39(1):199–209.
Christenson, Lynne E. 1991 Ethnobiology of the Theosophist Society San Diego, California (SDI-10, 531H). In The Sludge Management Facility Twelve Inch Force Main Accelerated Phase, San Diego Water Utilities, San Diego, California, Part II, Non Navy Property, Sunset Cliffs Shoreline Park to the San Diego River, by Timothy Gross, Stephen R. Van Wormer, and Mary Robbins-Wade, Attachment 2, pp. 1–11. Report to the City of San Diego Clean Water Program, San Diego, CA, from Affinis, El Cajon, CA.
Elliott, John F. 1985 History. In Excavations in Early Santa Ana: The OCTD Terminal Site [CA-ORA-103H], James Brock, editor, pp. 12–65. Report to Orange County Transit District, Garden Grove, CA, from ECOS Management Criteria, Cypress, CA.
Felton, David L., and Peter D. Schulz 1983 The Diaz Collection: Material Culture and Social Change in Mid-Nineteenth-Century Monterey. California Archaeological Reports, No. 23. Department of Parks and Recreation, Sacramento, CA.
Fink, Gary R. 1980 Rancho Guajome: Window on the Past, a Test of the Historic Resources at the Casa de Rancho Guajome. San Diego County Department of Parks and Recreation, San Diego, CA.
Foote, Edward B. 1892 Plain Home Talk Embracing Medical Common Sense. Murray Hill Publishing Company, New York, NY.
Galanter, Marc 1989 Cults and New Religious Movements. In Cults and New Religious Movements: A Report of the American Psychiatric Association, Marc Galanter, editor, pp. 25–40. American Psychiatric Association, Washington, DC.
Gordon, Jean, and Jan McArthur 1985 American Women and Domestic Consumption, 1800–1920: Four Interpretive Themes. Journal of American Culture 8(3):35–46.
Gross, Timothy, Stephen R. Van Wormer, and Mary Robbins-Wade 1991 The Sludge Management Facility Twelve Inch Force Main Accelerated Phase, San Diego Water Utilities, San Diego, California, Part II, Non Navy Property, Sunset Cliffs Shoreline Park to the San Diego River. Report to the City of San Diego Clean Water Program, San Diego, CA, from Affinis, El Cajon, CA.
Henretta, James A. 1978 Families and Farms in Pre-Industrial America. William and Mary Quarterly 35(1):3–32.
Henry, Susan L. 1982 Economic Scaling of Ceramics. In City of Phoenix, Archaeology of the Original Town Site, Blocks 1 and 2, pp. 322–335. Report to Central Phoenix Redevelopment Agency, Phoenix, AZ, from Soil Systems, Phoenix, AZ.
Henry, Susan L. 1987a A Chicken in Every Pot: The Urban Subsistence Pattern in Turn-of-the-Century Phoenix, Arizona. In Living in Cities: Current Research in Urban Archaeology, Edward Staski, editor, pp. 19–28. The Society for Historical Archaeology, Special Publication Series, No. 5, California, PA.
Henry, Susan L. 1987b Factors Influencing Consumer Behavior in Turn of the Century Phoenix, Arizona. In Consumer Choice in Historical Archaeology, Suzanne M. Spencer-Wood, editor, pp. 359–379. Plenum Press, New York, NY.
Henry, Susan L. 1991 Consumers, Commodities, and Choices: A General Model of Consumer Behavior. Historical Archaeology 25(2):3–14.
Henry, Susan L., and Patrick Garrow 1982 City of Phoenix Archaeology of the Original Town Site, Blocks 1 and 2: Part II—The Historic Component. Report to Central Phoenix Redevelopment Agency, Phoenix, AZ, from Soil Systems, Phoenix, AZ.
Hill, Thomas 1880 Hill’s Manual of Social and Business Forms. Moses Warren and Co., Chicago, IL.
Howe, Daniel Walker 1975 American Victorians as a Culture. American Quarterly 27(4):507–532.
Jones, Billy M. 1967 Health-Seekers in the Southwest, 1817–1900. University of Oklahoma Press, Norman.
Judge, William Avan 1892 The Cure of Diseases. The Path. 8 September:187–190. Reprinted 1975 in Echoes of the Orient: The Writings of William Avan Judge by Point Loma Publications, San Diego, CA.
Kamerling, Bruce 1980 Theosophy and Symbolist Art: The Point Loma Art School. Journal of San Diego History 36(4): 231–255.
Kellogg, J. H. 1885 Man, the Masterpiece: Or Plain Truths Plainly Told. Health Publishing Company, Battle Creek, MI.
Koch, Felix J. 1913 With the Theosophists at Point Loma. Overland Monthly 62(4):340–344.
Kuepper, Wilhelmine 1905 Nature Cure (Formerly Called Water Cure) or Home Treatment Without Medicine. John C. Wirsten Company, Philadelphia, PA.
Kupel, Douglas 1986 Part Two—Historical Analysis. In Bonita-Miguel Substation: Archaeological Investigations into the History and Prehistory of the Substation Area, pp. 128–196. Report to San Diego Gas and Electric Company, San Diego, CA, from Wirth Environmental Services, Division of Dames and Moore, San Diego, CA.
Levenstein, Harvy A. 1988 Revelation at the Table. Oxford University Press, New York, NY.
Miller, George L. 1980 Classification and Economic Scaling of Nineteenth-Century Ceramics. Historical Archaeology 14:1–40.
Pierce, R. V. 1895 The Peoples Common Sense Medical Adviser. World’s Dispensary Medical Association, Buffalo, NY.
Schlereth, Thomas J. 1991 Victorian America: Transformations in Everyday Life, 1876–1915. Harper Collins, New York, NY.
Shepherd, Don F. 1995 Education, Culture, and the Performing Arts in the Point Loma Theosophical Society: From Helena Blavatsky to Katherine Tingley. Master’s Thesis, Department of History, California State University, Fullerton.
South, Stanley 1977 Method and Theory in Historical Archaeology. Academic Press, New York, NY.
Spencer-Wood, Suzanne M. (editor) 1987 Consumer Choice in Historical Archaeology. Plenum Press, New York, NY.
Tannahill, Ray 1973 Food in History. Stein and Day, New York, NY.
Thomas, Samuel J. 1982 Nostrum Advertising and the Image of Women as Invalid in Late Victorian America. Journal of American Culture 5(3):104–112.
Tingley, Katherine (editor) 1903 Temperance Reform. The New Century 6(14):2. San Diego (San Diego Historical Society Research Archives), CA.
Tingley, Katherine (editor) 1904a English and American Stimulants. The New Century 7(39):4. San Diego (San Diego Historical Society Research Archives), CA.
Tingley, Katherine (editor) 1904b Ice, Alcohol, Health, and Longevity. The New Century 7(44):4. San Diego (San Diego Historical Society Research Archives), CA.
Tingley, Katherine (editor) 1904c A Prescription for Long Life. The New Century 7(10): 3. San Diego (San Diego Historical Society Research Archives), CA.
Tingley, Katherine (editor) 1904d The Secret of Patent Medicine Testimonials. The New Century 7(51):3. San Diego (San Diego Historical Society Research Archives), CA.
Tingley, Katherine (editor) 1904e Substitutes for Alcoholic Beverages. The New Century 7(44):4. San Diego (San Diego Historical Society Research Archives), CA.
Van Wormer, Stephen R. 1983a Beer, Wine, and Sardines with a Dash of Pepper Sauce: An Analysis of the Glass and Tin Cans of the Encino Roadhouse. Pacific Coast Archaeological Society Quarterly 19(1):47–66.
Van Wormer, Stephen R. 1983b Pio Pico Bottles, Tableware, and Domestic Glass. In Archaeological Report, Volume II, Data Report, Pio Pico Research Project, by Michael A. Hood, pp. 68–76. Report to State of California Department of Parks and Recreation Resource Protection Division, Sacramento, from Scientific Resource Surveys, Huntington Beach, CA.
Van Wormer, Stephen R. 1984 Analysis of Refuse Recovered from Two Privies at the Hubert Ranch, Oceanside, California. Manuscript, Ogden Environmental (formerly WESTEC Services), San Diego, CA.
Van Wormer, Stephen R. 1985 An Analysis of a Historic Trash Deposit at W-1696. Pacific Coast Archaeological Society Quarterly 21(4): 39–50.
Van Wormer, Stephen R. 1986 Historic Cultural Remains. In Archaeological Excavations at Los Peáasquitos Ranch House Resource Area, San Diego, Vol. 1, by Susan Hector and Stephen R. Van Wormer, pp. 90–136. Report to County of San Diego Department of Parks and Recreation, San Diego, CA, from RECON, San Diego.
Van Wormer, Stephen R. 1991a Even the Kitchen Sink: Archaeological Investigations of SDI-10258: The 1908 to 1913 San Diego City Dump. Report to the City of San Diego Development and Environmental Planning Division, San Diego, CA, from RECON, San Diego, CA.
Van Wormer, Stephen R. 1991b The Theosophical Society Dump. In The Sludge Management Facility Twelve Inch Force Main Accelerated Phase, San Diego Water Utilities, San Diego, California, Part II, Non Navy Property, Sunset Cliffs Shoreline Park to the San Diego River, by Timothy Gross, Stephen R. Van Wormer and Mary Robbins-Wade, pp. 51–104. Report to the City of San Diego Clean Water Program, San Diego, CA, from Affinis, El Cajon, CA.
Van Wormer, Stephen R. 1996a Cultural Resource Mitigation for the Home Avenue Trunk Sewer: Archaeological Data Recovery of a Portion of SDI-10, 528H the 1908 to 1913 City of San Diego Dump. Report to the City of San Diego Water Utilities/Engineering Departments, San Diego, CA, from RECON, San Diego, CA.
Van Wormer, Stephen R. 1996b Revealing Cultural, Status, and Ethnic Differences through Historic Artifact Analysis. Proceedings of the Society for California Archaeology 9:310–323.
Whorton, James C. 1982 Crusaders for Fitness: The History of American Health Reformers. Princeton University Press, Princeton, NJ.
Wright, Robert 1974 Reminiscences of Lomaland by Iverson L. Harris, in an interview with Robert Wright. Journal of San Diego History 20(3):1–32.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Van Wormer, S.R., Gross, G.T. Archaeological Identification of an Idiosyncratic Lifestyle: Excavation and Analysis of the Theosophical Society Dump, San Diego, California. Hist Arch 40, 100–118 (2006). https://doi.org/10.1007/BF03376717
Published:
Issue date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/BF03376717