There is a test failure - related to #22690 - maybe @chalasr can help here. It seems rethrowing was needed in the Symfony context so the symfony/debug handlers can do their job, but when using symfony/console inside Composer for example all I end up with is an unstyled error output from the native PHP uncaught exception handler.

I worked around this in composer/composer@af3e67e for the time being, as I wanted to render those type errors nicer, and also note I forced the stack trace to be shown for \Error (and its children) & \LogicException (not its children tho as things like InvalidArgumentException I wouldn't necessarily consider programming errors). Because getting error reports for things like type errors which are definitely program errors without stack trace is a real pain.

So feel free to close here if you think it's unreasonable, but I find the current state a slightly strange behavior for non-symfony-framework users of symfony/console.

Oh h*ck not this topic again 😅

Yes I saw there's some history there :) That's why I said it's fine for me to close as well, I could achieve what I needed to achieve on my end, so no big deal.

Sorry I didn't mean to close! Let me check this.

Closing as explained, too risky for 4.4 at least.