Skip to main content

Stack Exchange Network

Stack Exchange network consists of 183 Q&A communities including Stack Overflow, the largest, most trusted online community for developers to learn, share their knowledge, and build their careers.

Visit Stack Exchange
Asked
Modified yesterday
Viewed 1k times
5

I attempted to clarify butter for the first time. Based on the picture, I think there is to many solids in it. Is this butter clarified correctly ?

clarified butter

Here is what I did:

  • Boiled 2 sticks of kerrygold unsalted for about 8 minutes ( stirring frequently to prevent burning )
  • scooped of any solids while boiling
  • let it rest for 30 minutes ( no other foam formed on top )
  • carefully poured it trough cheescloth leaving the bottom parts behind
  • let sit overnight to solidify
New contributor
Willem D'Haeseleer is a new contributor to this site. Take care in asking for clarification, commenting, and answering. Check out our Code of Conduct.

3 Answers 3

7

I’ve never clarified butter before, but that looks kind of what like ghee looks like in my local store - kind of grainy with some oily/liquid bits. As I understand, clarified butter and ghee are both made up of a mix of fats that have varying melting points. When allowed to slowly cool, the ones with a higher melting point will solidify first, eventually leaving some of the fats that are liquid at room temperature.

To remedy that, you can re-melt everything, mix it well, then cool it in the fridge to have it cool homogeneously, without a chance for it to separate. When brought back to room temperature, it will stay well-mixed for the most part.

1

To clarify butter you should melt it at low heat, not boiling. If you brown the milk solids you're making ghee, the flavor is going to be more nutty.

Let the butter simmer gently, and the milk solids will rise to the top, forming a foam. The water will sink to the bottom. You want the middle layer, the butterfat.

Skim off the foam and pour the clear butterfat into a container, leaving the water and milk solids behind.

You could also melt the butter (in cubes) in the microwave, without stirring. Cool it down in the fridge and the layers will be separated.

And apparently you could also add cornstarch (1 ½ tsp for each ½ lb of butter) once the butter starts to simmer, keep simmering until the mixture stops foaming, and strain this through a coffee filter or cheesecloth: the cornstarch will separate the solids and the resulting liquid is the clarified butter.

1

We do clarify butter frequently - and... most of the other answers are very different from how we do it.

Least for us, we let the butter melt, and the foam form, and continue heating at medium heat until the foam starts to settle. No need to stir, just keep the heat low, and trust the process. Let it sink to the bottom. You want a golden coloured liquid, with a brown sediment at the bottom.

Adding a spig or two of curry leaf or moringa is optional. We do it, and it makes the smell even more glorious.

Decant the liquid. It'll recrystalise later but warmed up it will melt back into a liquid.

The water content should boil off, we're claifying not distilling.

While many commercial ghees are 'solid' - this isn't really part of the process. They're clarified 'less' for shelf life, and you'd want to re-melt it down anyway. You want a GOLDEN LIQUID, not a solid.

6
  • would you say that clarified butter and/or ghee are liquid or solid at room temperature? You said "It'll recrystalise later but warmed up it will melt back into a liquid." but also " You want a GOLDEN LIQUID, not a solid." I definitely agree that while warm you're expecting a golden liquid of the fats, just curious to clarify what you mean about what state you're expecting
    fyrepenguin
    –  fyrepenguin
    2025-10-13 04:00:23 +00:00
    Commented yesterday
  • Also, interestingly this Serious Eats article agrees with you, to a point. Basically, the separate-and-skim is apparently good for quick, larger batches but worse for small batches, while your preferred boil-off-the-water method is good for smaller batches or if you want more flavor, more like ghee. Tbh it sounds more like your method is closer to making ghee; as I understand clarified butter tends to be more neutral flavored since you're not cooking it as long
    fyrepenguin
    –  fyrepenguin
    2025-10-13 04:35:55 +00:00
    Commented yesterday
  • Our method, with a few changes is literally how we've been doing it for undreds of years. Sure we don't use butter from freshly churned yogurt (using fairly regular butter these days) but its pretty much how my ancestors, and their ancestors and so on have been doing it. I'd consider ghee and clarified butter to be synonyms.
    Journeyman Geek
    –  Journeyman Geek
    2025-10-13 06:18:18 +00:00
    Commented 22 hours ago
  • 1
    Also its not a 'cooling' thing. Fresh, cooled ghee is a liquid. Over time it'll sort of crystalise/set on the top, then gradually all the way. I'll check if we have the good stuff, and if so I can take a picture for my answer ;)
    Journeyman Geek
    –  Journeyman Geek
    2025-10-13 06:19:19 +00:00
    Commented 22 hours ago
  • Hmmmm, that’s interesting. I’m curious about the chemical process behind that. It sounds like a temperature thing (if say, your “room temperature” is very near to the melting point), but not if that crystallization happens over the course of weeks rather than a day or two.
    fyrepenguin
    –  fyrepenguin
    2025-10-13 06:35:08 +00:00
    Commented 22 hours ago

Your Answer

Reminder: Answers generated by AI tools are not allowed due to Seasoned Advice's artificial intelligence policy

Post as a guest

Required, but never shown

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge you have read our privacy policy.

Start asking to get answers

Find the answer to your question by asking.

Ask question

Explore related questions

See similar questions with these tags.

Morty Proxy This is a proxified and sanitized view of the page, visit original site.